the Holy Ghost over the bent
World broods with warm breast
and with ah! bright wings.
27 July 2009
THE ARCHBISHOP OF CANTERBURY, on COMMUNION, COVENANT, AND OUR ANGLICAN FUTURE
The Archbishop of Canterbury has written an essay titled, "Communion, Covenant, and our Anglican Future." I am sure responses will follow!
24 July 2009
ARTIFICIAL DEVICES
ARTIFICIAL DEVICES
A few days ago, I was leaving Anaheim, California. The work of the General Convention of the Episcopal Church was good and important, but I was ready to depart that region. The setting –a convention center in Anaheim—seemed artificial and unseasoned, without a history or developed character. In fact, the character of the place was Disneyland; how much wisdom or character can one hope to imbibe from an amusement park?
Nevertheless, that setting was my home for two weeks. My routine was the same. Rise early, prepare for committee meetings, encounter ideas and faith and people and agendas, walk from one air-conditioned room to another, ride on escalators and elevators, eat processed food quickly and absently, sit on the legislative floor and pay attention, do all this some more, and then try to be asleep by 11:00 so I could rise again at 5:00 am.
I must admit that, for all its sterility, the Anaheim Convention Center, with two central hotels, was a comfortable place to gather and do business. Yes, it was artificial; yes, it was also mechanically efficient for us.
Then, one day after I left Anaheim, I was sitting on a dock in Canada with my father, just after sunset. Since my childhood, I have travelled annually to that lake, with its rustic cabins and primitive challenges. The deep green hemlocks and pines, the rich white birch trees, the cold black water, the open sky, all overwhelm any human activity; artificial devices are weak and meager here. It is easy to be mesmerized by the sky.
With a few others, my father and I peered eagerly into the northwest horizon, waiting and watching. A slight cold front was breaking up the overcast day. The air was chilly, but the sky had cleared above some post sunset clouds.
Then, suddenly, we saw it. The International Space Station was soaring over the north. The orange white glow was speeding at 17,000 miles per hour, 405 miles away from us. In the twilight, only Vega and a couple of other stars were beginning to appear. But, as we focused on this man-made intrusion into space, we also made out distant objects way beyond humanity’s foray into the heavens.
I have watched that northern horizon many a night here in Ontario. I have seen amazing light shows from the Aurora Borealis. It is always beautiful. If “artificial” means man-made, or simulated, or forced, or contrived, then this part of God’s creation is the very antithesis of “artificial.”
But for humanity, “artificial” is all we have. All we can muster, by definition, are man-made attempts and offerings. In fact, the International Space Station, a true modern marvel, is the very height of “artificial.” It is a man-made contrivance, inserted into the far reaches of God’s creation. Though it is the result of creative science, it is also a piece of art, like a paint stroke across the sky’s canvas.
Yes, the International Space Station is a work of art. It reminds me of a deeper meaning to the word “artificial.” Etymologically, “artificial” can mean “belonging to art,’ or “made by art.” At our best, we human beings create from artistic desire. We plan, and build, and explore, with artistic visions.
One of the many marvels about the space station is that it is also a work of art by committee. It has been added to, and revised, and corrected more times than…well, more times than an urban office building, or an old house, or… a piece of government legislation.
The old adage is that one will never eat sausage again after one has seen the inside of a sausage factory and how the stuff is actually made. One will never want to enter politics after witnessing the journey of a single piece of legislation. One will never want to go to church again after serving on a vestry or board of elders.
But those factories and legislatures and vestries are all we have. All we have are artificial attempts, human-made pieces of art, often assembled by committee, to witness to truth and grace in the world. That’s what the General Convention of the Episcopal Church was. Yes, it was set in an artificial place (a place designed to work!), it was committee after committee, it was the work of humanity. I hope and pray, nonetheless, that it has served us well.
Artificial devices are all we have on this earth, and all we have above the earth. At their best, they are truly works of art, inspired by glorious visions. For all our foibles, the Episcopal Church has a glorious vision; we want to be orthodox and generous, faithful and honest. We want to be true to God and to God’s creation. We are human beings, but we are on the dock straining to see grace over the horizon. We are human beings, but we have glimpsed divine grace in the twilight.
(This article also appeared at a website named Episcopal Cafe (here), for which I write from time to time.)
A few days ago, I was leaving Anaheim, California. The work of the General Convention of the Episcopal Church was good and important, but I was ready to depart that region. The setting –a convention center in Anaheim—seemed artificial and unseasoned, without a history or developed character. In fact, the character of the place was Disneyland; how much wisdom or character can one hope to imbibe from an amusement park?
Nevertheless, that setting was my home for two weeks. My routine was the same. Rise early, prepare for committee meetings, encounter ideas and faith and people and agendas, walk from one air-conditioned room to another, ride on escalators and elevators, eat processed food quickly and absently, sit on the legislative floor and pay attention, do all this some more, and then try to be asleep by 11:00 so I could rise again at 5:00 am.
I must admit that, for all its sterility, the Anaheim Convention Center, with two central hotels, was a comfortable place to gather and do business. Yes, it was artificial; yes, it was also mechanically efficient for us.
Then, one day after I left Anaheim, I was sitting on a dock in Canada with my father, just after sunset. Since my childhood, I have travelled annually to that lake, with its rustic cabins and primitive challenges. The deep green hemlocks and pines, the rich white birch trees, the cold black water, the open sky, all overwhelm any human activity; artificial devices are weak and meager here. It is easy to be mesmerized by the sky.
With a few others, my father and I peered eagerly into the northwest horizon, waiting and watching. A slight cold front was breaking up the overcast day. The air was chilly, but the sky had cleared above some post sunset clouds.
Then, suddenly, we saw it. The International Space Station was soaring over the north. The orange white glow was speeding at 17,000 miles per hour, 405 miles away from us. In the twilight, only Vega and a couple of other stars were beginning to appear. But, as we focused on this man-made intrusion into space, we also made out distant objects way beyond humanity’s foray into the heavens.
I have watched that northern horizon many a night here in Ontario. I have seen amazing light shows from the Aurora Borealis. It is always beautiful. If “artificial” means man-made, or simulated, or forced, or contrived, then this part of God’s creation is the very antithesis of “artificial.”
But for humanity, “artificial” is all we have. All we can muster, by definition, are man-made attempts and offerings. In fact, the International Space Station, a true modern marvel, is the very height of “artificial.” It is a man-made contrivance, inserted into the far reaches of God’s creation. Though it is the result of creative science, it is also a piece of art, like a paint stroke across the sky’s canvas.
Yes, the International Space Station is a work of art. It reminds me of a deeper meaning to the word “artificial.” Etymologically, “artificial” can mean “belonging to art,’ or “made by art.” At our best, we human beings create from artistic desire. We plan, and build, and explore, with artistic visions.
One of the many marvels about the space station is that it is also a work of art by committee. It has been added to, and revised, and corrected more times than…well, more times than an urban office building, or an old house, or… a piece of government legislation.
The old adage is that one will never eat sausage again after one has seen the inside of a sausage factory and how the stuff is actually made. One will never want to enter politics after witnessing the journey of a single piece of legislation. One will never want to go to church again after serving on a vestry or board of elders.
But those factories and legislatures and vestries are all we have. All we have are artificial attempts, human-made pieces of art, often assembled by committee, to witness to truth and grace in the world. That’s what the General Convention of the Episcopal Church was. Yes, it was set in an artificial place (a place designed to work!), it was committee after committee, it was the work of humanity. I hope and pray, nonetheless, that it has served us well.
Artificial devices are all we have on this earth, and all we have above the earth. At their best, they are truly works of art, inspired by glorious visions. For all our foibles, the Episcopal Church has a glorious vision; we want to be orthodox and generous, faithful and honest. We want to be true to God and to God’s creation. We are human beings, but we are on the dock straining to see grace over the horizon. We are human beings, but we have glimpsed divine grace in the twilight.
(This article also appeared at a website named Episcopal Cafe (here), for which I write from time to time.)
23 July 2009
22 July 2009
The Most Reverend Katharine Jefferts Schori Writes to the Church
Several interpretations, as always, have followed the General Convention of the Episcopal Church. The Presiding Bishop has written her evaluation here, and her actual words are worth more than those of the various media outlets!
Grace and peace to all of you!
Grace and peace to all of you!
21 July 2009
The Heavens Tell of the Glory of God
At 10:31 tonight, the International Space Station will pass over my head, just after a solar eclipse occurs on the other side of the world.
Enjoy!
Enjoy!
17 July 2009
A Letter to Archbishop Rowan Williams from The Episcopal Church Presiding Officers
The Most Reverend Katharine Jefferts Schori and Bonnie Anderson, presiding officers of The Episcopal Church, have written a letter to Archbishop Rowan Williams, explaining Resolution D025 from General Convention 2009.
Its description is linked below, and it includes a link to the actual letter itself.
http://www.episcopalchurch.org/79901_112694_ENG_HTM.htm
Enjoy!
Sam
Its description is linked below, and it includes a link to the actual letter itself.
http://www.episcopalchurch.org/79901_112694_ENG_HTM.htm
Enjoy!
Sam
THE STATEMENT INTRODUCING c056
A STATEMENT INTRODUCING C056
To the House of Deputies
General Convention – 17 July 2009
THE VERY REVEREND SAM CANDLER
CHAIR OF COMMITTEE 13
Whether you are a first-time observer, or a veteran, to General Convention, you know that the issue of blessing same gender commitments has been intense and controversial. For a generation, every General Convention has been considering this matter; surely we know every contrasting argument by now. We have heard all manner of voices – the progressive and the traditional, the shrill and the gentle, the painful and the pastoral.
At this 2009 convention, on the last day of our gathering, Committee 13 brings forward Resolution C056. We believe that it represents an elegant blend of theological care, ecclesiastical breadth, and pastoral generosity. Our cognate committee received eleven different initial resolutions on same-sex blessings and/or marriage, rites, we heard over two hours of open testimony, and we listened sensitively to various perspectives in our own committee.
My fellow deputies on Committee 13 are wonderful, and I give thanks for them. And let me say, too, that we especially appreciated working with the bishops in our cognate committee. This convention is wise to depend upon cognate committees to develop resolutions, resolutions which both houses, legislatively, might then find suitable; and we worked together gracefully in Committee 13. The House of Bishops received our resolution first, took some time with it, then took some more time; and they have amended our cognate version.
Now, the House of Deputies Committee 13 believes we have a fine current document. We desire decency and order in the Episcopal Church, theological decency and liturgical order; and this resolution supplies a gentle and modest way forward. We recommend that this house, without amendment, concur with the House of Bishops.
Sam Candler
To the House of Deputies
General Convention – 17 July 2009
THE VERY REVEREND SAM CANDLER
CHAIR OF COMMITTEE 13
Whether you are a first-time observer, or a veteran, to General Convention, you know that the issue of blessing same gender commitments has been intense and controversial. For a generation, every General Convention has been considering this matter; surely we know every contrasting argument by now. We have heard all manner of voices – the progressive and the traditional, the shrill and the gentle, the painful and the pastoral.
At this 2009 convention, on the last day of our gathering, Committee 13 brings forward Resolution C056. We believe that it represents an elegant blend of theological care, ecclesiastical breadth, and pastoral generosity. Our cognate committee received eleven different initial resolutions on same-sex blessings and/or marriage, rites, we heard over two hours of open testimony, and we listened sensitively to various perspectives in our own committee.
My fellow deputies on Committee 13 are wonderful, and I give thanks for them. And let me say, too, that we especially appreciated working with the bishops in our cognate committee. This convention is wise to depend upon cognate committees to develop resolutions, resolutions which both houses, legislatively, might then find suitable; and we worked together gracefully in Committee 13. The House of Bishops received our resolution first, took some time with it, then took some more time; and they have amended our cognate version.
Now, the House of Deputies Committee 13 believes we have a fine current document. We desire decency and order in the Episcopal Church, theological decency and liturgical order; and this resolution supplies a gentle and modest way forward. We recommend that this house, without amendment, concur with the House of Bishops.
Sam Candler
HOLY LONGING AND CHURCH BLESSINGS
HOLY LONGING AND CHURCH BLESSINGS
It’s Thursday night, my twelfth night in Anaheim, the night before the last day of General Convention 2009. We are all tired, longing to be home; and we have faced grueling decisions. We have passed a budget with large cuts; they were necessary. We have made last second amendments and grown frustrated with parliamentary procedure. We have struggled with votes forcing us to think quickly about church and government issues. We have had to think quickly about the deepest theology and about the kindest courtesies. We have laughed thankfully with old friends. We have met some bright new faces. We have made some people rejoice; the same decision has offended others.
And tomorrow will be the last day. With it will arrive one of our most controversial resolutions, C056, presenting a way forward on the matter of blessing committed same gender relationships. Most of us have heard every argument for, and every argument against, going forward on this matter.
I have been chair of the “Prayer Book, Liturgy, and Church Music” committee, which has been crafting this resolution for the last several days; and, as chair of the committee, I will present it on the floor of the House of Deputies tomorrow. I will urge recommendation of the resolution. In fact, I hoped we would pass a similar resolution six years ago, because I desire good theological and liturgical order. Six years ago, we consented to the consecration of a partnered gay man as bishop, and I believe that was a good decision; but I wish we had been able to construct, first, the orderly way that we could recognize and bless his union. That would have been “decent and in order.”
There is a good chance C056 will pass. The tenor of the House of Deputies seems to be favorable. But I will also feel for my conservative friends in the House of Deputies, and across the church. They are already a disappointed minority in many places (certainly here), and my call is to minister to disappointed minorities. They will find comfort in a large majority across the Anglican Communion of churches, and in many individual parishes in The Episcopal Church; that is well and good.
I will pray, tomorrow night, for that perfected heavenly community where our love and affection overwhelm the differences between us. All of us know that holy longing. None of us is there yet, though we are given the grace to glimpse it in our smaller communities –maybe in our parishes and, God willing, in our own marriages and partnerships.
I am thinking of my partner now, whom I miss and long to see after two weeks. The two of us have known joy and disappointment together; we have known pain and grace together; through divine grace, we have even known God through each other. Our union is blessed by God and by the Church. It is because I believe in that Church blessing, that it should be available to everyone, that I will be supporting C056.
It’s Thursday night, my twelfth night in Anaheim, the night before the last day of General Convention 2009. We are all tired, longing to be home; and we have faced grueling decisions. We have passed a budget with large cuts; they were necessary. We have made last second amendments and grown frustrated with parliamentary procedure. We have struggled with votes forcing us to think quickly about church and government issues. We have had to think quickly about the deepest theology and about the kindest courtesies. We have laughed thankfully with old friends. We have met some bright new faces. We have made some people rejoice; the same decision has offended others.
And tomorrow will be the last day. With it will arrive one of our most controversial resolutions, C056, presenting a way forward on the matter of blessing committed same gender relationships. Most of us have heard every argument for, and every argument against, going forward on this matter.
I have been chair of the “Prayer Book, Liturgy, and Church Music” committee, which has been crafting this resolution for the last several days; and, as chair of the committee, I will present it on the floor of the House of Deputies tomorrow. I will urge recommendation of the resolution. In fact, I hoped we would pass a similar resolution six years ago, because I desire good theological and liturgical order. Six years ago, we consented to the consecration of a partnered gay man as bishop, and I believe that was a good decision; but I wish we had been able to construct, first, the orderly way that we could recognize and bless his union. That would have been “decent and in order.”
There is a good chance C056 will pass. The tenor of the House of Deputies seems to be favorable. But I will also feel for my conservative friends in the House of Deputies, and across the church. They are already a disappointed minority in many places (certainly here), and my call is to minister to disappointed minorities. They will find comfort in a large majority across the Anglican Communion of churches, and in many individual parishes in The Episcopal Church; that is well and good.
I will pray, tomorrow night, for that perfected heavenly community where our love and affection overwhelm the differences between us. All of us know that holy longing. None of us is there yet, though we are given the grace to glimpse it in our smaller communities –maybe in our parishes and, God willing, in our own marriages and partnerships.
I am thinking of my partner now, whom I miss and long to see after two weeks. The two of us have known joy and disappointment together; we have known pain and grace together; through divine grace, we have even known God through each other. Our union is blessed by God and by the Church. It is because I believe in that Church blessing, that it should be available to everyone, that I will be supporting C056.
15 July 2009
THE HEADLINES SIZZLE
THE HEADLINES SIZZLE
I rejoiced yesterday with many of my friends in The Episcopal Church after the passage of D025; it is an honest proclamation of full inclusion of gays and lesbians in the church and an honest proclamation of our commitment to the wider Anglican Communion. That is its beauty. I also sat with friends who were discouraged, for fear that we had taken a step apart from the wider Anglican Communion. I disagree with their assessment, but I care for them.
Meanwhile, the headlines, as usual, have all the sizzle but none of the meat. The snippet headlines want the world to believe that The Episcopal Church has overturned a moratorium on the consecration of gays or lesbians, or has repealed the 2006 resolution B033. The substance of resolution D025 is far richer than that. It has re-affirmed the commitment of The Episcopal Church both to the full inclusion of gays and lesbians, and to the wider Anglican Communion. The Episcopal Church refuses to believe it must choose between the two.
I am among that apparently growing minority who believes that the actual wording of 2006-B033 did not place a legislative moratorium on the consecration of gays or lesbians as bishops. I acknowledge that it was interpreted that way after its passage. I also acknowledge that some close friends of mine considered themselves excluded because of it.
In fact, however, B033 was always interpreted variously. A major reason it passed the General Convention of 2006 was because it mentioned neither “moratorium” nor “gays and lesbians.” Thus, there never was a formal “moratorium” in place in the Episcopal Church which has now been broken. There may have been informal moratoria, within the minds of individuals and nominating committees and dioceses, and that fact has always been legitimate in the church. At this convention, D025 simply does not mention overturning a moratorium, because no legislative moratorium is in place.
I do agree that certain relationships within the Anglican Communion of churches are strained. Those are the relationships, generally, who see sexuality issues as determinative for communion. I do not agree. There are plenty of healthy, vigorous, and missional relationships across lines in the Anglican Communion which are satisfied to let sexuality issues be secondary issues. Uniform opinion on the sexuality issues of our time –or any time-- should not be the basis for Christian communion. Indeed, they should not be determinative for Christian covenant either – but more on that at a later time!
I rejoiced yesterday with many of my friends in The Episcopal Church after the passage of D025; it is an honest proclamation of full inclusion of gays and lesbians in the church and an honest proclamation of our commitment to the wider Anglican Communion. That is its beauty. I also sat with friends who were discouraged, for fear that we had taken a step apart from the wider Anglican Communion. I disagree with their assessment, but I care for them.
Meanwhile, the headlines, as usual, have all the sizzle but none of the meat. The snippet headlines want the world to believe that The Episcopal Church has overturned a moratorium on the consecration of gays or lesbians, or has repealed the 2006 resolution B033. The substance of resolution D025 is far richer than that. It has re-affirmed the commitment of The Episcopal Church both to the full inclusion of gays and lesbians, and to the wider Anglican Communion. The Episcopal Church refuses to believe it must choose between the two.
I am among that apparently growing minority who believes that the actual wording of 2006-B033 did not place a legislative moratorium on the consecration of gays or lesbians as bishops. I acknowledge that it was interpreted that way after its passage. I also acknowledge that some close friends of mine considered themselves excluded because of it.
In fact, however, B033 was always interpreted variously. A major reason it passed the General Convention of 2006 was because it mentioned neither “moratorium” nor “gays and lesbians.” Thus, there never was a formal “moratorium” in place in the Episcopal Church which has now been broken. There may have been informal moratoria, within the minds of individuals and nominating committees and dioceses, and that fact has always been legitimate in the church. At this convention, D025 simply does not mention overturning a moratorium, because no legislative moratorium is in place.
I do agree that certain relationships within the Anglican Communion of churches are strained. Those are the relationships, generally, who see sexuality issues as determinative for communion. I do not agree. There are plenty of healthy, vigorous, and missional relationships across lines in the Anglican Communion which are satisfied to let sexuality issues be secondary issues. Uniform opinion on the sexuality issues of our time –or any time-- should not be the basis for Christian communion. Indeed, they should not be determinative for Christian covenant either – but more on that at a later time!
14 July 2009
How I Spent the Summer
Click here to see a photograph and article about my usual day at General Convention.
http://www.episcopalchurch.org/107152_112503_ENG_HTM.htm
The article describes the work of Committee 13 and it also links to the resolution that we are finally proposing. It was hard work, but I enjoyed the way that the bishops and the deputies worked gracefully and elegantly together.
Here is the statement I released:
“As we report C056 out of our cognate committee, I give thanks that our committee has worked with such grace and elegance. We tried to be sensitive to every voice on this matter, and we realize that the issue of same gender blessings has been contentious in the past. I have actually had great fun! Both the bishops and the deputies in the room shared the same goal, to produce a resolution that has a reasonable probability of being passed by both houses. It has not been easy, but we believe we have something that can achieve that goal. God gave us the grace to be of remarkably common mind. I am quite optimistic.”
Grace and peace to you!
http://www.episcopalchurch.org/107152_112503_ENG_HTM.htm
The article describes the work of Committee 13 and it also links to the resolution that we are finally proposing. It was hard work, but I enjoyed the way that the bishops and the deputies worked gracefully and elegantly together.
Here is the statement I released:
“As we report C056 out of our cognate committee, I give thanks that our committee has worked with such grace and elegance. We tried to be sensitive to every voice on this matter, and we realize that the issue of same gender blessings has been contentious in the past. I have actually had great fun! Both the bishops and the deputies in the room shared the same goal, to produce a resolution that has a reasonable probability of being passed by both houses. It has not been easy, but we believe we have something that can achieve that goal. God gave us the grace to be of remarkably common mind. I am quite optimistic.”
Grace and peace to you!
13 July 2009
FLOOR SPEECH IN FAVOR OF D025
SAM CANDLER
SPEAKS FOR RESOLUTION D025 (Anglican Communion: Commitment and Witness to Anglican Communion)
12 July 2009
I speak in favor of D025, and I commend the legislative committee for its energy and work. This past Wednesday, Archbishop Rowan Williams, addressed the global economic crisis with this remedy: he urged a re-ordering of society that looked to small-scale enterprises, local initiatives, and local relationships; I think he suggested that these local efforts would lead the whole world into a new, and a truthful, and an authentic, economy.
I suggest that these same principles of local development, local truth-telling, and honest relationship, are the keys to the economy of our Anglican Communion of churches as well. The Anglican Communion of churches is not comprised of instruments. We are comprised of relationships. This resolution honors those relationships. This resolution honors the presence of Christ in our fellow pilgrims around the Anglican world, the presence of Christ in our gay and lesbian brothers and sisters, the presence of Christ in the House of Deputies, and the presence of Christ in the House of Bishops.
The Episcopal Church is obliged to hold dear two critical relationship commitments. One commitment is to the full inclusion of gays and lesbians in our churches; the second commitment is to communion in the wider Anglican Communion of churches. We can do both. When we honor those relationships, we honor the incarnation of Jesus Christ in the world. God has made of one blood ALL the peoples of the earth, and sent his blessed Son to preach peace to those who are far off AND to those who are near. We can preach the same peace; we can do both.
The Very Reverend Sam Candler
Clergy Deputy from the Diocese of Atlanta
SPEAKS FOR RESOLUTION D025 (Anglican Communion: Commitment and Witness to Anglican Communion)
12 July 2009
I speak in favor of D025, and I commend the legislative committee for its energy and work. This past Wednesday, Archbishop Rowan Williams, addressed the global economic crisis with this remedy: he urged a re-ordering of society that looked to small-scale enterprises, local initiatives, and local relationships; I think he suggested that these local efforts would lead the whole world into a new, and a truthful, and an authentic, economy.
I suggest that these same principles of local development, local truth-telling, and honest relationship, are the keys to the economy of our Anglican Communion of churches as well. The Anglican Communion of churches is not comprised of instruments. We are comprised of relationships. This resolution honors those relationships. This resolution honors the presence of Christ in our fellow pilgrims around the Anglican world, the presence of Christ in our gay and lesbian brothers and sisters, the presence of Christ in the House of Deputies, and the presence of Christ in the House of Bishops.
The Episcopal Church is obliged to hold dear two critical relationship commitments. One commitment is to the full inclusion of gays and lesbians in our churches; the second commitment is to communion in the wider Anglican Communion of churches. We can do both. When we honor those relationships, we honor the incarnation of Jesus Christ in the world. God has made of one blood ALL the peoples of the earth, and sent his blessed Son to preach peace to those who are far off AND to those who are near. We can preach the same peace; we can do both.
The Very Reverend Sam Candler
Clergy Deputy from the Diocese of Atlanta
STARDATE LEGISLATIVE DAY SIX: TO BOLDLY GO WHERE NO ONE HAS GONE BEFORE?
STARDATE LEGISLATIVE DAY SIX:
TO BOLDLY GO WHERE NO ONE HAS GONE BEFORE?
It’s Monday, July 13, 2009, Day Whatever on the legislative calendar, and I feel like Captain Kirk, on the starship “Enterprise,” recording another stardate in his log. I do not know cerebrally what legislative day this is (it is actually Day Six), but I do know emotionally that we have turned. As of yesterday, the House of Deputies began to feel like a body operating efficiently and dramatically, operating with direction and focus. After a few days of ‘warm-up” votes and floor debates, we were galloping on the back stretch yesterday.
The primary drama of Sunday, of course, was our vote on D025, having to do with our commitments to both the wider Anglican Communion and to the full participation of gays and lesbians in our own Episcopal Church. I was not surprised by the floor debate, but the margin in which the motion prevailed was noteworthy; it passed by roughly a seven to three margin. For me, this translates to something just over a two-thirds vote. Should similar issues, especially around parliamentary procedure, which often require two-thirds vote, arise again, then the House of Deputies may have a two-thirds vote block on those issues.
This morning, I have heard concern and disappointment from some quarters –along with great joy from places like Canada. Voices from the far right and the far left proclaim a similar headline: the House of Deputies has “overturned” 2006-B033 and its moratorium on the election of gay bishops – or words similar. But I have a major problem with that headline: B033 (the 2006 resolution) never said that; and I, for one, never interpreted it as a moratorium. I believe that much of our anxiety occurred by buying into that interpretation. If that resolution had meant moratorium, it would have said “moratorium.” I do not think the House of Deputies voted to overturn anything.
Now, of course, more drama awaits. If D025 is to prevail for the entire convention, then the House of Bishops will have to pass it in the same form in which the House of Deputies did yesterday. Much of the immediate feedback, especially from places outside The Episcopal Church, is obviously designed to pressure the bishops.
Then, there’s another issue: the matter of same gender blessings and commitment rites – or whatever title one prefers. My own committee, Committee 13, continues to discuss that matter. Whatever we report out will go first to the House of Bishops for initial action, and secondly to the House of Deputies (the reverse order of D025).
In great science fiction, such as Star Trek, the physical setting is futuristic, but the actual subject matter is the age-old mystery of human life and human relationships, and even divine relationships. Today, at General Convention, Stardate Legislative Day Six, some might proclaim that we are “boldly going where no one has gone before.” But this is simply a new setting for our common task and age-old mission: to witness to the grace and salvation of Jesus Christ.
TO BOLDLY GO WHERE NO ONE HAS GONE BEFORE?
It’s Monday, July 13, 2009, Day Whatever on the legislative calendar, and I feel like Captain Kirk, on the starship “Enterprise,” recording another stardate in his log. I do not know cerebrally what legislative day this is (it is actually Day Six), but I do know emotionally that we have turned. As of yesterday, the House of Deputies began to feel like a body operating efficiently and dramatically, operating with direction and focus. After a few days of ‘warm-up” votes and floor debates, we were galloping on the back stretch yesterday.
The primary drama of Sunday, of course, was our vote on D025, having to do with our commitments to both the wider Anglican Communion and to the full participation of gays and lesbians in our own Episcopal Church. I was not surprised by the floor debate, but the margin in which the motion prevailed was noteworthy; it passed by roughly a seven to three margin. For me, this translates to something just over a two-thirds vote. Should similar issues, especially around parliamentary procedure, which often require two-thirds vote, arise again, then the House of Deputies may have a two-thirds vote block on those issues.
This morning, I have heard concern and disappointment from some quarters –along with great joy from places like Canada. Voices from the far right and the far left proclaim a similar headline: the House of Deputies has “overturned” 2006-B033 and its moratorium on the election of gay bishops – or words similar. But I have a major problem with that headline: B033 (the 2006 resolution) never said that; and I, for one, never interpreted it as a moratorium. I believe that much of our anxiety occurred by buying into that interpretation. If that resolution had meant moratorium, it would have said “moratorium.” I do not think the House of Deputies voted to overturn anything.
Now, of course, more drama awaits. If D025 is to prevail for the entire convention, then the House of Bishops will have to pass it in the same form in which the House of Deputies did yesterday. Much of the immediate feedback, especially from places outside The Episcopal Church, is obviously designed to pressure the bishops.
Then, there’s another issue: the matter of same gender blessings and commitment rites – or whatever title one prefers. My own committee, Committee 13, continues to discuss that matter. Whatever we report out will go first to the House of Bishops for initial action, and secondly to the House of Deputies (the reverse order of D025).
In great science fiction, such as Star Trek, the physical setting is futuristic, but the actual subject matter is the age-old mystery of human life and human relationships, and even divine relationships. Today, at General Convention, Stardate Legislative Day Six, some might proclaim that we are “boldly going where no one has gone before.” But this is simply a new setting for our common task and age-old mission: to witness to the grace and salvation of Jesus Christ.
12 July 2009
THE HOUSE OF DEPUTIES AND THE HOUSE OF BISHOPS: IS ONE THE SENIOR HOUSE?
THE HOUSE OF DEPUTIES AND THE HOUSE OF BISHOPS:
IS ONE THE SENIOR HOUSE?
Some people say it to tease, and some people say it as a matter of principle; but, the General Convention of The Episcopal Church will often hear the House of Deputies referred to as “the senior house” to the House of Bishops. Because this General Convention may experience some deeper disagreements between those houses than in recent years, it might be good to enjoy a bit of history.
First, for observers: In the Episcopal Church, the House of Bishops consists of all our bishops of the church. The House of Deputies consists of four elected priests and four more elected laypersons from each of the regular dioceses of The Episcopal Church. At General Convention, a successful resolution must pass both legislative houses in the same form.
So, why is the House of Deputies considered the senior house? In the 1780’s, there was no formal Episcopal Church. Anglican Christians (those connected to the Church of England) found themselves organizing and setting up leadership along three different structures. First, there were those Anglicans in the southern colonies below Connecticut, including Virginia and South Carolina, who were great believers in representative government. Many of their Anglican churches had existed for a long time without the presence of a bishop at all. They had grown accustomed to organizing and supervising themselves. Nevertheless, they wanted bishops, because bishops distinguished their identity from the new world Protestant bodies.
Secondly, there were Anglicans in the north, especially in Connecticut, who followed the high church principles of Samuel Seabury. The Diocese of Connecticut organized itself to have no lay representation at all. A group of clergy elected Samuel Seabury to be bishop and sent him across the Atlantic for ordination. He ended up being consecrated in November of 1784, in Scotland, not England, because the English Parliament would not allow anyone to be consecrated bishop without vowing allegiance to the English monarchy.
Thirdly, there were those many Anglicans who were deeply influenced by The Great Awakening. The early Methodist leaders were mostly Anglican, and they would finally decide, at the Christmas Conference in 1784, to elect and ordain two of their own as ‘supervisors” – Thomas Coke and Francis Asbury. Obviously, this group would separate from the other Anglicans in the new world; that was a great loss.
The first two general conventions of the Episcopal Church met in 1785 and 1786, without the Diocese of Connecticut, and, thus, without any bishops. They were following the Reverend William White, who had plans for the church to be democratically operated but otherwise to conform as much as possible to the Church of England. In 1786, English Parliament relaxed its ordination laws, and William White and Samuel Provoost (from New York) were permitted to be ordained in England for service in the United States.
So, it was not until the 1789 General Convention of the Episcopal Church that bishops were present. In fact, this date serves as the formal establishment of (what is now) The Episcopal Church. 1789 is the date of the church’s first real constitution; it created a House of Bishops, which would be allowed to veto the House of Deputies if it had enough votes!
Today, it probably does not matter who is the “senior house.” What is critical to our communion is that legislation is not authorized until both houses act favorably on it. By necessity, resolutions must begin in one house or the other. Some resolutions are first acted upon in the House of Bishops, some first in the House of Deputies. Each house (and its associated legislative committees) is wise to craft legislation that they believe, in good faith, might pass in the other house. So, it finally does not matter who is the “senior house.” But it does matter that The Episcopal Church has contributed a democratic and representative form of church government in a catholic and apostolic tradition. That may be the same sort of ecclesiastical wonder as was the United States Constitution wonder! May God be with us!
IS ONE THE SENIOR HOUSE?
Some people say it to tease, and some people say it as a matter of principle; but, the General Convention of The Episcopal Church will often hear the House of Deputies referred to as “the senior house” to the House of Bishops. Because this General Convention may experience some deeper disagreements between those houses than in recent years, it might be good to enjoy a bit of history.
First, for observers: In the Episcopal Church, the House of Bishops consists of all our bishops of the church. The House of Deputies consists of four elected priests and four more elected laypersons from each of the regular dioceses of The Episcopal Church. At General Convention, a successful resolution must pass both legislative houses in the same form.
So, why is the House of Deputies considered the senior house? In the 1780’s, there was no formal Episcopal Church. Anglican Christians (those connected to the Church of England) found themselves organizing and setting up leadership along three different structures. First, there were those Anglicans in the southern colonies below Connecticut, including Virginia and South Carolina, who were great believers in representative government. Many of their Anglican churches had existed for a long time without the presence of a bishop at all. They had grown accustomed to organizing and supervising themselves. Nevertheless, they wanted bishops, because bishops distinguished their identity from the new world Protestant bodies.
Secondly, there were Anglicans in the north, especially in Connecticut, who followed the high church principles of Samuel Seabury. The Diocese of Connecticut organized itself to have no lay representation at all. A group of clergy elected Samuel Seabury to be bishop and sent him across the Atlantic for ordination. He ended up being consecrated in November of 1784, in Scotland, not England, because the English Parliament would not allow anyone to be consecrated bishop without vowing allegiance to the English monarchy.
Thirdly, there were those many Anglicans who were deeply influenced by The Great Awakening. The early Methodist leaders were mostly Anglican, and they would finally decide, at the Christmas Conference in 1784, to elect and ordain two of their own as ‘supervisors” – Thomas Coke and Francis Asbury. Obviously, this group would separate from the other Anglicans in the new world; that was a great loss.
The first two general conventions of the Episcopal Church met in 1785 and 1786, without the Diocese of Connecticut, and, thus, without any bishops. They were following the Reverend William White, who had plans for the church to be democratically operated but otherwise to conform as much as possible to the Church of England. In 1786, English Parliament relaxed its ordination laws, and William White and Samuel Provoost (from New York) were permitted to be ordained in England for service in the United States.
So, it was not until the 1789 General Convention of the Episcopal Church that bishops were present. In fact, this date serves as the formal establishment of (what is now) The Episcopal Church. 1789 is the date of the church’s first real constitution; it created a House of Bishops, which would be allowed to veto the House of Deputies if it had enough votes!
Today, it probably does not matter who is the “senior house.” What is critical to our communion is that legislation is not authorized until both houses act favorably on it. By necessity, resolutions must begin in one house or the other. Some resolutions are first acted upon in the House of Bishops, some first in the House of Deputies. Each house (and its associated legislative committees) is wise to craft legislation that they believe, in good faith, might pass in the other house. So, it finally does not matter who is the “senior house.” But it does matter that The Episcopal Church has contributed a democratic and representative form of church government in a catholic and apostolic tradition. That may be the same sort of ecclesiastical wonder as was the United States Constitution wonder! May God be with us!
AN ANGLICAN KINGDOM OR AN ANGLICAN COMMUNION?
AN ANGLICAN KINGDOM OR AN ANGLICAN COMMUNION?
It was an honor for the General Convention of the Episcopal Church to hear Archbishop Rowan Williams speak to us on Wednesday, July 8, 2009 (and again on the following day). Archbishop Rowan spoke eloquently and incisively on Wednesday evening about economic crisis. Among his fine points was his observation that it will be small-scale enterprises, local initiatives, and local relationships which will lead the world into a new economy. He mentioned efforts like Habitat For Humanity.
I suggest that those same principles of local development, local truth-telling, and honest relationship, are the keys to the economy of our Anglican Communion of churches as well. Some claim that our church is in a crisis just as urgent as that of our world economy. (Even if one claims that we are not in true crisis, we can certainly acknowledge that elements of our communion are anxious.) Following Archbishop Rowan’s economic principles, the remedy to our anxiety (or crisis) will not be a hierarchical declaration, from the top down. Our Anglican Communion will derive strength from local communities being faithful to how God leads them in their particular circumstances and in their particular time. Indeed, I believe this is the genius of our Anglican tradition.
I enjoy references to the “UK,” the “United Kingdom.” This past week, I began to recognize some obvious historical differences between a united kingdom and a united states. Our Anglican heritage finds its historical roots in a nation that is now known as the United Kingdom. That nation’s constituent parts were once governed by royalty – by kings and queens. In shorthand, this meant top-down rule, often far-removed from genuine relationships with the population. On the other hand, The Episcopal Church finds its historical roots in a nation that is now known as the United States. Our nation’s constituent parts were once independent states, much different from “kingdoms;” and our country continues to negotiate the best ways to apply both federal and state government.
It strikes me that what we know now as the Anglican Communion of Churches might once have more accurately been called the Anglican Kingdom of Churches. After all, The Anglican Church historically spread along the very same lines as English colonialism.
Today, are we an Anglican Kingdom of Churches, or are we an Anglican Communion of Churches? A secular kingdom “lords it over” its subjects, making rules that are, at best, sincere, but, at worst, tyrannical. A old-fashioned king usually “rules” at a distance, from above. (Fairy tales fantasize about kings who disguise themselves in order to mingle with their people.) On the other hand, a communion’s authority involves dispersed leadership; a communion values idea and inspiration from even the lowest members of itself.
Kingdom is about hierarchy. Communion is about relationship. Of course, Jesus’ parables of the kingdom of God are another matter; Jesus’s description of the kingdom of God overturns the world’s understanding of “kingdom.” At any rate, The Anglican Communion of churches rarely operates well as hierarchy. The Anglican Communion of churches is at our best when we honor relationships. In doing so, we honor the incarnation of Jesus Christ in the world.
It was an honor for the General Convention of the Episcopal Church to hear Archbishop Rowan Williams speak to us on Wednesday, July 8, 2009 (and again on the following day). Archbishop Rowan spoke eloquently and incisively on Wednesday evening about economic crisis. Among his fine points was his observation that it will be small-scale enterprises, local initiatives, and local relationships which will lead the world into a new economy. He mentioned efforts like Habitat For Humanity.
I suggest that those same principles of local development, local truth-telling, and honest relationship, are the keys to the economy of our Anglican Communion of churches as well. Some claim that our church is in a crisis just as urgent as that of our world economy. (Even if one claims that we are not in true crisis, we can certainly acknowledge that elements of our communion are anxious.) Following Archbishop Rowan’s economic principles, the remedy to our anxiety (or crisis) will not be a hierarchical declaration, from the top down. Our Anglican Communion will derive strength from local communities being faithful to how God leads them in their particular circumstances and in their particular time. Indeed, I believe this is the genius of our Anglican tradition.
I enjoy references to the “UK,” the “United Kingdom.” This past week, I began to recognize some obvious historical differences between a united kingdom and a united states. Our Anglican heritage finds its historical roots in a nation that is now known as the United Kingdom. That nation’s constituent parts were once governed by royalty – by kings and queens. In shorthand, this meant top-down rule, often far-removed from genuine relationships with the population. On the other hand, The Episcopal Church finds its historical roots in a nation that is now known as the United States. Our nation’s constituent parts were once independent states, much different from “kingdoms;” and our country continues to negotiate the best ways to apply both federal and state government.
It strikes me that what we know now as the Anglican Communion of Churches might once have more accurately been called the Anglican Kingdom of Churches. After all, The Anglican Church historically spread along the very same lines as English colonialism.
Today, are we an Anglican Kingdom of Churches, or are we an Anglican Communion of Churches? A secular kingdom “lords it over” its subjects, making rules that are, at best, sincere, but, at worst, tyrannical. A old-fashioned king usually “rules” at a distance, from above. (Fairy tales fantasize about kings who disguise themselves in order to mingle with their people.) On the other hand, a communion’s authority involves dispersed leadership; a communion values idea and inspiration from even the lowest members of itself.
Kingdom is about hierarchy. Communion is about relationship. Of course, Jesus’ parables of the kingdom of God are another matter; Jesus’s description of the kingdom of God overturns the world’s understanding of “kingdom.” At any rate, The Anglican Communion of churches rarely operates well as hierarchy. The Anglican Communion of churches is at our best when we honor relationships. In doing so, we honor the incarnation of Jesus Christ in the world.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)